Matters requiring attention, the formal findings US bank examiners use to tell a board what must be fixed, now come with a regulatory definition and a materiality test. On 27 August 2026 the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation issued a joint final rule that defines “unsafe or unsound practice” in regulation and sets uniform standards for when examiners may issue an MRA.

The agencies want examiners to prioritise material financial risks over policy, process and documentation concerns. For banks, and for the fintechs that depend on them, the change alters what an exam finding means, how much of it must reach the board, and which issues are left to management’s discretion.

Matters requiring attention now need a link to material financial harm

Under the final rule, as summarised in OCC Bulletin 2026-40, an agency may only issue an MRA for a practice, act or failure to act that falls into one of two buckets:

  • A prudential concern: it is contrary to generally accepted standards of prudent operation and, if continued, could reasonably be expected under current or reasonably foreseeable conditions to materially harm the bank’s financial condition or present a material risk of loss to the Deposit Insurance Fund, or it has already caused material harm to the bank’s financial condition.
  • A legal breach: it is an actual violation of a banking or banking-related law or regulation.

The OCC states plainly that this uniform standard “narrows the scope of practices that would support the issuance of an MRA” while still allowing examiners to identify risks early. A weak policy document or an incomplete procedure manual, on its own, no longer clears the bar unless it connects to material financial harm or a real violation.

Defining an unsafe or unsound practice: likely, not merely possible

The rule also defines “unsafe or unsound practice” for enforcement under section 8 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 USC 1818). The definition requires conduct that is contrary to generally accepted standards of prudent operation and that, if continued, is likely to materially harm the bank’s financial condition or present a material risk of loss to the Deposit Insurance Fund, or that has already materially harmed its financial condition.

Two details in the OCC bulletin matter most for compliance teams. First, the harm must be likely rather than merely possible. Second, “financial condition” means capital, asset quality, earnings, liquidity or sensitivity to market risk, and the definition expressly excludes risks to a bank’s reputation that are unrelated to its financial condition.

Supervisory tool Threshold under the final rule What the bank must do
Enforcement for an unsafe or unsound practice Harm to financial condition or loss to the Deposit Insurance Fund is likely if the conduct continues, or harm has already occurred Comply with the enforcement action
Matter requiring attention (MRA) Harm could reasonably be expected under current or reasonably foreseeable conditions, harm has already occurred, or there is an actual legal violation Remediate in line with the agency’s stated expectations
Other violation An actual violation that does not lead to an enforcement action or MRA Remediate the violation; no further direction unless required by law
Supervisory observation A weakness that does not rise to MRA level Management decides whether to act; no expectation it goes to the board

Supervisory observations and “other violations” take the overflow

Findings that fall below the MRA line do not disappear. The rule authorises two lighter channels. A supervisory observation is an informal comment on a weakness; unlike an MRA, it does not create an expectation that it will be presented to the board, and the decision whether to implement any enhancement stays with the bank. An “other violation” is a violation for which the agency neither takes an enforcement action nor issues an MRA. Here the agency may require remediation, but the OCC says it will not direct the bank to take any further action unless the law requires it.

The rule also addresses how findings are justified. The agencies will use objective facts and sound reasoning, and examiners must share with the bank the basis for identifying an unsafe or unsound practice or issuing an MRA.

Tailoring: bigger and riskier banks face a lower materiality bar

The narrower standard is not uniform in effect. The final rule requires the agencies to tailor enforcement and MRAs to the risks associated with a bank’s capital structure, complexity, activities, asset size and other financial risk factors. As those risks increase, the OCC bulletin says, three things happen: the materiality threshold for harm falls, the assessment of harm becomes more granular, and remediation requirements and expectations of prudent operation rise.

Banks with complex or concentrated activities should not assume the rule is a blanket loosening.

How the FDIC is applying the MRA rule in examinations

The FDIC set out its implementation in FIL-53-2026, which adds Part 305 to its rules and applies to all FDIC-supervised institutions. The key operational changes are:

  • Fewer labels: the FDIC is ending its use of Matters Requiring Board Attention and Supervisory Recommendations. Outstanding items will be reviewed and either redesignated as MRAs or closed out.
  • Violation MRAs limited: the FDIC intends generally to reserve MRAs for substantive violations, treating other actual violations as “other violations” that may still need remediation.
  • Clearer reports: MRA comments in Reports of Examination will generally describe the issue, explain why material harm, material risk of loss to the Deposit Insurance Fund or an actual violation is present, and state the corrective action expected. Report comments are expected to be more concise.
  • Wide scope: Part 305 covers risk management, specialty examination areas and consumer protection examination and enforcement, but not enforcement actions against institution-affiliated parties.

What sponsor banks and their fintech partners should expect

Banking-as-a-Service programmes lean heavily on third-party oversight, documentation and process controls, exactly the areas the agencies want examiners to weigh against material financial risk. Under the new standard, those concerns support an MRA only if the agency can tie them to reasonably foreseeable material financial harm or show an actual legal violation. Weaknesses that fail that test are more likely to arrive as supervisory observations, which leave the response to the bank.

That does not mean compliance programmes can shrink. Actual violations of banking or banking-related laws, including consumer protection rules, can still produce MRAs, and the tailoring provision means banks with complex partner programmes may face a lower materiality threshold. Sponsor banks should also expect fintech partners to ask whether a given request stems from a formal MRA, an “other violation” or a discretionary observation, because the answer now carries different obligations. For background on the controls examiners have expected from partner banks, see our guide to risk management for sponsor banks.

Matters requiring attention FAQs

Can an examiner still issue an MRA for a weak policy or poor documentation?

Only if the weakness is contrary to prudent operation and could reasonably be expected to materially harm the bank’s financial condition or create a material risk of loss to the Deposit Insurance Fund, or if it amounts to an actual legal violation. Documentation gaps that meet neither test are expected to be raised, if at all, as supervisory observations. The agencies say the goal is to prioritise material financial risks over policy, process and documentation concerns.

Does a supervisory observation have to go to the board?

No. The OCC says a supervisory observation does not create a requirement or expectation that it will be presented to the board of directors. Decisions about whether to implement any suggested enhancement are left to the bank.

What happens to existing FDIC Matters Requiring Board Attention?

The FDIC is ending the use of Matters Requiring Board Attention and Supervisory Recommendations for examination findings. Outstanding items will be reviewed and either redesignated as MRAs where appropriate or closed out. Banks should confirm the status of each open item with their examination team.

Can reputational risk alone support an unsafe or unsound practice finding?

Not under the new definition. The OCC bulletin says the definition focuses on material harm to financial condition, meaning capital, asset quality, earnings, liquidity or sensitivity to market risk. Risks to reputation that are unrelated to financial condition are excluded.

Does the rule apply to fintechs that are not banks?

The OCC says the rule explicitly limits its scope to institutions the agencies supervise, so it does not directly govern non-bank fintechs. Fintechs are affected indirectly through their bank partners, whose MRAs and remediation plans often shape partner programme requirements.

Will large banks benefit as much as community banks?

Not necessarily. The rule requires tailoring by capital structure, complexity, activities and asset size, and as those risks rise the materiality threshold falls and remediation expectations increase. Larger or more complex banks may therefore still see MRAs on issues that would not trigger one at a smaller institution.

The MRA rule shifts the burden of proof onto examiners to show why a finding matters financially or legally, and gives banks a written standard to point to when they disagree. For sponsor banks, lenders and fintechs, the practical work is to map every open finding to the new categories and to keep documenting why their controls protect financial condition, not just process. Readers tracking how supervisory expectations are being narrowed elsewhere can also see our analysis of AI model risk management rules for US banks and the lessons from Synapse’s collapse for BaaS risk.